Are warehouse clubs worth it?

photo by Kevinee
Pay a membership fee, buy in bulk, and save a ton of money. Not so fast, fellow frugalitarian. Warehouse clubs aren’t always the tightwad utopia they seem to be. I let my membership expire, and I don’t plan on renewing it, mostly because of my distance from the closest store. OK, I might miss poking around the seasonal merchandise, and my kids might miss grazing the free samples of food. But, for the most part, I’m not missing the way my eyes glazed over whenever I walked in and that surprised feeling when I handed over large sums of cash at the checkout. I never left that place without spending more than I intended to. It’s too easy to convince yourself that products such as giant jars of pickles, peanut butter and pancake syrup are the best deals around. I always felt a bit ridiculous hauling all the mega-sized products, too. It was the joyful abundance versus shameful gluttony factor.
My lessons learned are these: Some products aren’t meant to last a year and get a little gross after a while. It’s not always a deal simply because it comes in a bigger container, and it’s definitely not saving me anything if the product goes to waste. You need room for all those bulk products, too. I do have an upright freezer, but I have limited storage space for products that aren’t frozen.
It can be helpful to shop there. Be sure to do your homework and compare prices for the same products in other stores. Many of my readers share lists of products they have found cheaper at warehouse clubs. Some of these items include baby supplies, milk, baking supplies, produce, gas, meat, pet food, printer ink, laundry detergent and prescriptions. Visit on a nonmember free-pass day. You can ask their customer-service desk for a pass, and some stores offer free passes on their Web sites. You can go with family or friends who have memberships, too.
Ask whether your local warehouse store accepts coupons, issues store coupons or lets you pay a surcharge to shop without buying a full membership. You should know your rate of use for the products you buy so you’re not wasting anything. Also, do you have to travel far to get to the store? With simple math, you can see whether it’s worth it for you to join based on these points alone.
However, if you’re not a disciplined shopper, it can be a budget buster. Don’t forget that warehouse stores carry far fewer products than most grocery stores. You can face a long wait time during checkout, and don’t expect the same level of customer service aisle to aisle that you’re used to at the grocery store. On the upside, warehouse clubs often offer products you won’t find easily in other stores.
If you discover that warehouse-club shopping saves you money, here are some tips.
– Compare prices on warehouse store-brand products, too.
– Lunch can be cheap there. Some offer free drink refills.
– Check unit pricing.
– Check for discount prices at new-product, free-sample stations.
– At Sam’s Club, a “C” on the price tag indicates a product that has been discontinued. Sam’s Club markdown price ends in a penny. At Costco, products ending with 97 cents are markdowns, and an asterisk indicates a discontinued item. — Michelle, Tennessee
– Above all else, avoid temptation.
While I don’t find a membership worth it for my family, plenty of people are saving a lot of money by shopping at warehouses. Only you can decide whether it’s worth it for your family.


If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!






I agree, I have found that when you are as cheap as we are, there is little to be had in these warehouses that are a good deal. So many of my friends are snookered into thinking everything in there is a ‘deal’. With the exception of certain otc meds and occasionally a jar of olive oil, very little is discounted any more than the typical wal-mart prices.
You have a nice blog, i will visit again!
Happy to have you here.
One more thought about wholesale clubs:
We belong to Sam’s off and on. We join and shop for a year, but before expiration date, we stock up on the things we like to buy most, nuts being one thing. We like to buy almonds and walnuts in quantity, but keep them in the ‘frig or freezer. Then we let our membership expire for several months. When we run out of everything we like to buy there, we join again. That way, we aren’t paying as much to belong.
Carolyn K
Hi Sara:
First, I want to say how much I really enjoy your columns (which I read in the Chicago Sun-Times). You so well come up with great details we can use.
I just finished this article. Like before you bring up different items to contemplate that I would not have thought of but are very important and better prepares me before making any decision.
I want to say thank you for your column.
I just came across your post here. I have to say, some things are not a bargain but many things are. I save a lot of money by shopping at Costco. For one things like bread, specialty cheeses, laundry detergent, flour, sugar, rice, beans, cooking oils, kitty litter, vitamins, and many staples are much much cheaper than grocery stores. You just need to keep up on prices of items in your local stores and know what you are saving on. I happen to save a lot of money via Costco. If I wasn’t up on things, then yes, I could see where it might not be very budget friendly. Warehouse shopping has been wonderful in my home. The key is to know what to buy and what not to buy.
Leave your response!
Feed on
Categories
Popular topics
Frugal & simple living »
Take the eat-at-home challenge
photo by Jenny Downing
Dining out is costly. It tends to be the weak area in a family budget. Curbing over-processed or fast food and eating out at restaurants has become easier for a lot of people, but for some people, nothing seems to work. If you continue to eat out frequently and tend to make poor choices or overspend, you can start a food-rule game to help you wean off …
Frugal Cooking »
No-oven-required desserts
photo by alibree
No-bake recipes are quick and easy. Their simplicity makes them ideal for kids to create (very little wait time) or on days you’re in a hurry or don’t feel like turning on the oven. Best of all, there’s minimal cleanup.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter
2 cups sugar
1/2 cup milk
4 tablespoons cocoa powder
1/2 cup peanut butter
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
3 cups quick-cooking oats
Add the first 4 ingredients …
Frugal Home & family »
Cut back or do without
photo by paul swansen
When you’re living lean, it seems like you can’t cut any more corners. Often, there are things you simply don’t want to give up. You get used to modern conveniences and want to enjoy life. But if you think about, there’s quite a bit you could cut back on if you had to, and some things you might not even miss if you got rid of them …
Question & Answer »
Freeze herbs in ice cube trays
photo by suavehouse113
DEAR SARA: I had to buy fresh parsley for a sauce I recently made. I have a bunch left over. Can I chop it and freeze it? — Lisa, Georgia
DEAR LISA: Yes, you can freeze parsley. Chop the parsley and place it into an ice cube tray. Top each ice cube tray cubbie with water. You want to use about 1/4 cup water for every cup of parsley. …
Reader Frugal Tips »
Make budget-friendly banana desserts
photo by hlkljgk
Frozen bananas are a tasty treat. Dip a whole frozen banana on a stick or frozen chopped banana into melted chocolate, then roll it into toppings such as sprinkles, crushed cookies or nuts or shredded coconut. You can use frozen bananas in smoothies, added to a bowl and topped with yogurt and granola or muesli, or combined with peanut butter and a bit of milk to make a …
You might also like:
Recent Posts
Most Commented
Most Viewed